Doubt and the Honest Questions of Adult Faith - For Men

John 20:24–29Luke 7:18–23Isaiah 35:5–6Isaiah 61:1Matthew 27:46Psalm 13Psalm 73Galatians 2:1–10Joshua 4:1–9Psalm 77:11–14Matthew 28:16–20Matthew 1:23Matthew 28:16–20

Men’s doubt often runs underground. It rarely surfaces in small groups because weakness is not what men’s circles tend to reward. This study invites men to bring that hidden struggle into the light — to see doubt not as failure, but as part of a mature and honest faith. Through the stories of Thomas, John the Baptist, David’s raw psalms, and Paul’s journey to Jerusalem “to be sure he had not run in vain,” participants will see that even the heroes of Scripture wrestled with uncertainty — and that each found clarity through community, conversation, and God’s gracious presence among His people. Each session creates space for men to explore their own questions and to mark moments when God has revealed Himself clearly — “mile markers” to remember when faith feels thin. Along the way, they’ll discover that doubt is best handled not in isolation but within Kingdom relationships — through honest dialogue, shared prayer, and mutual ministry that draw men deeper into alignment with God’s purposes. In the end, this is a study about love that holds steady through confusion, trust that grows in tension, and the God who meets men honestly where they are — often through one another — and who, to illustrate that He is not afraid of our doubt, entrusted the Great Commission itself to a community that still included doubters.

What's Included

When you pull this study into your workspace, these items come with it.

Lessons6
Teaching sessions adapted for your audience.
Handouts6
One handout per lesson when this deliverable is included.
Discussion Guides0
Questions and prompts for teachers and parents.
Slides0
Presentation decks for classroom use.

What You'll Study

When Faith Feels Thin

John 20:24–29

Bringing Doubt Into the Light

Learning Objectives

Participants will recognize that doubt is a normal part of mature faith and that Jesus meets His followers personally in their uncertainty. They will identify areas of hidden doubt in their own lives and discuss how bringing those questions into honest community can open the way for renewed trust.

Questions from the Prison Cell

Luke 7:18–23

When God Doesn’t Act as Expected

Learning Objectives

Participants will understand that even faithful servants like John the Baptist experienced confusion when God did not act as expected. They will explore how dialogue, prayer, and engagement with others can help reframe disappointment and realign their expectations with God’s redemptive purposes.

Honest Psalms, Honest Men

Psalm 13; Psalm 73

Praying Our Doubt

Learning Objectives

Participants will see how David’s psalms model honest prayer in seasons of doubt. They will practice expressing lament and trust together, discovering that worshiping through uncertainty strengthens faith more than withdrawing in silence.

To Be Sure I Have Not Run in Vain

Galatians 2:1–10

Seeking Clarity in Community

Learning Objectives

Participants will grasp that clarity often comes through Kingdom relationships rather than solitary reasoning. They will examine Paul’s meeting with the Jerusalem leaders as an example of communal discernment and identify trusted believers with whom they can process their own questions.

Mile Markers of Faith

Joshua 4:1–9; Psalm 77:11–14

Remembering God’s Faithfulness

Learning Objectives

Participants will learn to establish “mile markers” — personal memories of God’s faithfulness — as anchors for future seasons of uncertainty. They will share these testimonies within community, affirming that remembered grace and mutual encouragement sustain faith when feelings falter.

Sent Even While Some Doubted

Matthew 28:16–20

Commissioned in Community

Learning Objectives

Participants will marvel that Jesus entrusted the Great Commission to a community that included doubters. They will see that God’s mission advances not through perfect certainty but through shared obedience and relational faithfulness. They will identify how staying engaged in Kingdom community and mission helps transform lingering doubts into active trust.

Actual Lesson Preview

A real rendered lesson for Adults from this study — a preview, not the full content.

Sample Content

Setting the Scene (5 min) This section provides the necessary context to understand John’s question and Jesus’ answer in their biblical and emotional setting. John the Baptist is imprisoned for confronting Herod’s sin, his public ministry abruptly ended. The one who once confidently pointed to Jesus as “the Lamb of God” now sits alone in confinement, hearing reports about Jesus’ works. Yet something doesn’t add up. John expected the Messiah to bring judgment and deliverance, but instead Jesus is healing, forgiving, and eating with sinners. The Kingdom looks different than John imagined. Jesus’ response is deeply personal: He doesn’t rebuke John’s question but points to the evidence of God’s reign breaking into the world — the blind see, the lame walk, the poor hear good news. In essence, Jesus says, “Look again, John. The Kingdom is advancing, just not in the way you expected.” Transition: Let’s slow down and observe carefully what the text actually says before we rush to interpret it.* Observation — What does the text say? (10 min) This section helps participants engage directly with the biblical words, noticing details that form the foundation for interpretation. What emotions or circumstances might have led John to send his disciples to Jesus with this question? What specific things does Jesus point to in His response, and what do they reveal about what is happening around Him? What phrase or detail in Jesus’ reply stands out to you most, and why might it have mattered to John? Transition: Now that we’ve noticed what’s in the text, let’s explore what it means — both for John’s faith and for ours.*

This study adapts to your church

When you bring this study into your workspace, it adapts to your theological convictions, your teaching context, and your audience. No other curriculum does this.

Get This Study →Start free trial

Requires a paid subscription. View plans.